Derry’s Opening Day Win Shows Promise – but Cohesion Still Lacking

Josh Thomas scored in added time to secure an opening-day victory at the Brandywell for Tiernan Lynch’s side.

The Candystripes endured a busy off-season and the return to league action had been highly anticipated, with many tipping Derry as genuine title contenders. The arrivals of James Clarke, Darragh Markey and Rob Slevin from fellow Premier Division sides weakened rivals, while further reinforcements came from abroad, including Thomas on loan and the return of James McClean.

With five members of the starting XI not at the club last season, some early disjointedness felt inevitable, and that was evident during a scrappy first half. Both sides showed signs of rust after a three-month break from league football, with Derry lining up in the same 4-2-3-1 shape used in last week’s President’s Cup, McClean and Carl Winchester operating as the double pivot.

McClean’s unfamiliarity with the role was exposed in the build-up to Sligo Rovers’ opener. Across his career, just 13 of his 672 appearances have come in central midfield, which amounts to under two percent, and his instincts remain those of a wide player rather than a number six.

When an overhit cross from the left was recycled on the right, Jad Hakiki positioned himself between McClean and left-sided centre-back Rob Slevin. With the delivery coming from his flank, Slevin was required to protect his zone, leaving the responsibility with McClean. As Hakiki subtly stepped backwards into space, McClean failed to track the movement, allowing the attacker to be picked out unchallenged and put the visitors ahead.

Jad Hakiki vs Derry

The most notable aspect of Derry’s play in possession was how aggressively the fullbacks pushed on. Both Alex Bannon and Brandon Fleming completed more passes in the opposition half than in their own, underlining how high Derry looked to pin Sligo back.

That approach nearly paid dividends late in the first half when Fleming delivered a dangerous ball across goal that James Clarke was just unable to reach. Bannon had also continued his run into the box, hoping the cross would be cut back to him instead.

One of the advantages of deploying McClean in midfield is his ability to operate in a quarterback-style role. While the fullbacks advanced, McClean stayed back to dictate play, affording himself time on the ball. Ninety percent of his passes in the opposition half found their target.

The equaliser eventually came through one of those high-flying fullbacks. Bannon received possession in the right half-space, beat his man and struck the ball superbly into the top-right corner.

Josh Thomas’ performance closely mirrored his display in the President’s Cup. The former Drogheda forward was lively throughout, repeatedly carrying the ball over long distances. His pace proved a constant threat, with Sligo’s defenders struggling to contain him, while his ability to control the ball at speed stood out.

As was the case last week, however, his finishing remained an issue. The Welshman registered five shots before the 90-minute mark, missing two big chances.

On the sixth attempt, Thomas finally delivered. Receiving the ball around 50 yards from goal, he drove forward with pace, brushed past Gareth McElroy and capped his performance with a composed finish into the bottom-left corner from just inside the box.

There is clearly a highly talented player in Thomas, but the 23-year-old remains raw. He is capable of creating chances on his own, but against sides like Shamrock Rovers or Shelbourne, he is unlikely to be afforded six opportunities.

The performance from Derry City showed clear promise and reinforced why they are viewed as genuine title contenders. However, improvements are still required. The opening goal was avoidable, Josh Thomas could have scored a hat-trick, and the likes of James Clarke and Michael Duffy did not reach the levels they are capable of.

If the pieces begin to click, and Derry continue to see their fullbacks pose a consistent attacking threat, McClean dictate play from deep, and Clarke and PFAI Player of the Year Michael Duffy rediscover their best form, the signs point towards a serious push for a first league title in 29 years.

Jamie Daly

Jamie Daly is our Editor in Chief as well as a co-host for our podcast. He is currently studying Journalism and Politics at the University of Galway.